SVTFOE (SkyXAnon) Chapter 2: The Secret Sister

>Wake up again. Annnnd you aren’t dead yet! This is a blessing. Truly.
>Last night was relatively uneventful. You and Star made the nachos, some dip, and even some jalapeno poppers. Then you went and watched a bunch of rabbits and other wildlife get murdered. Ahh, the circle of life. Throughout the whole thing, Star seemed conflicted. On one hand, she thought the bunnies were cute, but the eagles and their razor sharp claws seemed to drive her into a wild excitement. And it seems like, for now, her little crush on you has been vanquished. Awkwardness hadn’t reared its ugly head again, and with Oskar taking her out tonight, you no longer had to worry about it. For once, things were finally working out. It was actually going to be ok-
>*WHAM!* *CRRAAAACK*
>”ANON!”
AHHHHHHHHH! WHAT THE FUCK!!!!!!!
>”AHHHHHHHHHHH!!!!!”
AHHHHHHHH WHY THE HELL ARE YOU YELLING!?
>”AHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH!!!!!!!”
Star...STAR! STOP!
>You spring out of bed and grab at her face, hoping to seize her lips and stop her piercing screams from reverberating throughout the room.
>”AHHMMNPhnp-”
SHHHHH!!!
>Star’s face completely freezes. She looks at you like a deer caught in the headlights. Your hands firmly grasp her chubby cheeks together, stopping her from making a peep. Actually now that you think about it...This was too easy. No counterpunch, no judo throw, nope, just a whole lot of nothing. This is unusual. You try to get a good look at her face but she refuses to look you in the eye. Is she… is she blushing?
Damn it Star, you’re going to give me a heart attack if you keep barging in here like that every morning.
>You unclasp your hands from her mouth.
“Sorry Anon! I’m just in some really serious trouble right now and I have no idea what to do!”
Ohh no...
>You peer at your clock. 10am.
It's not even noon yet! What trouble? What’s happening and why am I instantly involved again!?
>”Anon it's just that… I completely forgot! I’m such an idiot! Ohh man, I’m Starring it up so bad right now. Why do I do this to myself?”
Forgot what? Can you just tell me what's wrong already?
>”My sister!”
Yo-your sister? Wait. What? I thought you were an only child?
>”Only child!? HUH? Who the heck told you that?”
Uhhhh… well I don’t know if you… well…I thought uhh...Marco...uhhm... I...I don’t really remember, now that you mention it
>”Of course you don’t Anon. My older sister is a bit of a black sheep in the family. Nobody really likes to bring her up. Bad memories. She cut off a mermaids tail. 6 years ago, I think, when she was only 12. She lost her right to be queen for it, as per tradition. She’s even a bigger rebel than I am, I guess. Total badgirl. Yeaaaahehehe. Anyway, my parents and her don’t really talk very much anymore, but she contacted me out of the blue just this morning. I feel terrible for her Anon, she’s kinda in a bad place in her life right now. She has nobody she can depend on. A completely lonely mess of a girl with nowhere to turn. Sooo… I sorta… invited her here.”
Oh. Well that's good then, what's the problem with that? You'll get to spend time with her.
>”The problem? The problem is she’s gonna be here TONIGHT! I’m supposed to be going on a date with Oskar! She has nobody to hang with!”
So who cares, no big deal, just reschedule your date or something.
>”No way Jose! I...I HAVE to go Anon. This is my ONE chance to get with OSKAR GREYSON! You don’t understand, he’s one of those cool, badboy types! You only get one shot with those type of guys! He’ll be off getting some other girl tomorrow. I’ll LOSE MY CHANCE! MY LIFE WILL BE RUINED!”
Cmon Star… You’re overreacting.
>“UGGH!!!  I’m such a terrible sister too, first I have to bail on her and then I can’t even find someone to keep her company!”
>Damn it, won’t anything shut this girl up? That bed looks so comfortable right now.
>”I’m screwed Anon! SCREWED! I’M HAVE TO CHOOSE BETWEEN BEING ALONE OR BEING WITHOUT MY FAMILY! HOW AM I SUPPOSED TO DO THAT?!”
>OH GOD! PLEASE SHUT UP! YOU HAVE TO DO SOMETHING SHUT HER UP!
I’LL DO IT! I'LL DO IT OK!? I’ll hang out with her tonight, alright? I got it. NOW PLEASE, STOP YELLING!
>Star’s face explodes from pure strife into excitement in an instant. Her sudden change of mood takes you by surprise, nearly knocking you back onto your bed from the sheer shock of it.
>”Do you really mean it Anon!? DUDE! You’re a lifesaver! Oh my god thank you SO much I swear I’ll make this up to you I promise!”
>Star jumps up and down in place in a fit of glee. You have to admit, Star’s really cute when she gets all excited.
Uhh… Do you… have a picture of her?
>”Why yes! I thought you’d never ask.”
>Star pulls out a suspiciously glittery envelope from her overalls. As she opens it, glitter pours out all over your carpet. Like… at least a half pound of it. God...fucking...damn it.
>”Uhh...ignore that for now, sorry, I’ll clean it up later.”
I hate you.
>”Which one is it here, nope nope no-YEP! There ya go. That's my sister, the one and only Sky Butterfly.”
>She must be kidding. If it wasn’t for Star’s distinct red horns and childish get-up, you’d barely be able to tell them apart. Standing there next to Star was what you assumed to be her doppelganger. A girl around the same height, same build, same eyes, same cheeks, same face, but different style of hair and dress. She wore a more reserved and elegant look. Earrings, flat colors, shoes instead of boots, a very simple dress, and to top it off, a teal highlight in her hair... It made her appear, at least to you, much more serious and collected than her little sister standing next to her, giving her bunny ears in her rainbow overalls.
>”Hmm, you don’t have much to say do you Anon? Are ya a little...starstruck?”
Huh?
>”She’s really pretty isn’t she? That's my sis! Yep. We’re super similar too. We have alot of the same interests and hobbies, we actually share more in common than anyone I know! She’s just been so busy living out in the countryside and all. And I haven’t gotten as much of a chance to sneak out and visit her now that I’ve been here.”
Hmm, so Sky huh? You Butterfly girls have such original names.
>”Heyyy… You better not say that around my Dad. He’s killed people for less than that.”
Jeeze, forget I said anything. So. she’s your older sister? How much older again?
>”Four years.”
Four?
>”Yes, Four.”
Four years?
>”FOUR. YEARS. Four of them”
Alright alright. So that makes her...eighteen?
>”Yep! That’s right Anon. She’s my 18 year old sister. Hey, whats with that look? You better not get any ideas Anon!”
What? Me? I wouldn’t dream of having ideas. N-nope! No ideas here.
>”Good. I think she’s freshly single anyway sooo...ya know. Just saying. Back off.”
Hey, for the record, you have the idea OK? Not me.
>”Whatever you say Anon. Hey so, I’m gonna go ahead and get ready for my date. Sky should be here later tonight. Try to at least be a gentleman ok? I’m going to call her and tell her I can’t make it. And Anon?”
Yes, warden?
>”You better behave. I don’t want to hear about you mistreating her. Treat her like you would treat me”
Uhhhh… I don’t think that's a good idea.
>”Just shut up and listen to me ok? No bad Anon tonight. Be good, for this one time. Just let loose, be yourself. I guarantee you’ll like her. Got it!? Oh yea. One more thing... I know where you live Anon”
Yes… yes ma’am.
>Star makes her way towards the door with slitted eyes and a serious grin. She takes her two fingers and points at her eyes, then yours. She grabs at the door and swings it open with unnecessary force. She leaps to the other side, then slowly closes it while glaring at you...
>A couple awkward seconds pass and you’ve decided you’re getting the last word. You open your door up in a huff and yell out after her.
Hey Star!!! Don’t forget.
>”Huh?”
I know where you live too you damn bug!
>The door to the basement slams loudly in response. GOTTEM!
>Well, looks like you’re going on a surprise date with Star’s older sister. Who looks just like her. And apparently acts just like her, but more rebellious, and more stylish. But... is also older than Star. And legal. Legally aged. And you’ve never met her before. Hell, you didn’t even know she existed. It seems like tonight could go horribly wrong. Knowing your luck, it will, and you’ll have a new type of Star waking you up tomorrow. A morning star. In your skull.